Navigating Counseling

In the book "Competent to Counsel," Jay Adams argues that Christians should not rely solely on professional counseling but instead should look to the Bible as the ultimate source of guidance for addressing their emotional, psychological, and spiritual needs. He contends that the secular approach of psychiatry, which relies heavily on drugs and Freudian therapy, is limited in its ability to truly help people.

While his focus on the importance of Scripture in counseling is commendable, it is also important to recognize that professional counseling and psychiatry can be beneficial for some individuals. Mental health issues can be complex, and a multifaceted approach that includes both traditional professional counseling coupled with biblical guidance may be the most effective way to address them.

At the same time, Adams' critique of the state of psychiatry today raises valid concerns about the overreliance on medication and the tendency to pathologize normal human emotions and behaviors. It is essential to recognize that mental health diagnoses are not always clear-cut and that we live in a culture that throws drugs at everything and everyone, even our young children.  

So as Jay Adams poses the question, where does this leave us? It is essential to approach counseling and mental health care with an open mind and a willingness to consider multiple perspectives. Christians can certainly benefit from the guidance of Scripture, but it is also important to recognize the value of professional counseling and the need for a holistic approach to mental health care. 

In my humble opinion, the ultimate goal should be to promote healing and growth in all areas of a person's life. This healing can come from spiritual guidance, coaching, therapy, or medication.

About the Author